Asphalt Resurfacing vs Replacement: Which Is Better?

Know Which Method Brings Optimal Results

Choosing between asphalt resurfacing vs replacement can save property owners time and money. However, when faced with damaged or aging pavement, deciding between these options isn’t always easy. Both methods offer unique benefits depending on the specific needs and conditions of the surface.

Assessing Your Pavement’s Condition

The first step in determining whether to choose resurfacing or replacement is to assess the current condition of your asphalt. Factors such as cracks, potholes, drainage problems, or extensive wear can influence your decision. If the foundation or base layer is still structurally sound, resurfacing could be a viable option, saving you from the expense of full replacement.

What Does Asphalt Overlaying Include?

Asphalt resurfacing involves adding a new layer of asphalt over the existing pavement. This process addresses minor issues and provides a fresh surface for improved aesthetics and performance. It’s an efficient solution for pavements that have maintained their structural integrity but show signs of surface-level wear. However, if there are significant underlying issues like sub-base failure, resurfacing may not suffice.

When Replacement Is Necessary

Complete asphalt replacement may be necessary when significant damage affects the entire depth of the pavement, such as substantial cracking throughout the surface or foundational issues within the asphalt layers. While this method can be more costly upfront, it provides a longer-lasting solution by comprehensively addressing all underlying problems. To determine if this approach is warranted, evaluate the overall condition of your asphalt for visible damages and consider the lifespan and usage of the pavement area. Additionally, consider future maintenance costs and needs while considering your budget constraints and timing requirements.

Making the Cost-Effective Decision

Ultimately, choosing between asphalt overlaying or replacement comes down to cost-effectiveness and longevity. A complete replacement may be the best route if longevity is more important than immediate cost savings. If short-term cost savings are crucial, and the pavement structure allows, opting for resurfacing could fulfill your immediate needs while extending the life of your pavement.

Expert Advice on Asphalt Resurfacing vs Replacement Solutions

For residents in Farragut, TN, choosing between asphalt resurfacing vs replacement is important to fix the issue. At Capitol Paving LLC, we are committed to helping clients understand their options clearly and comprehensively. For expert guidance tailored to your needs, call us at (423) 481-3855.